These beverages by the Oki company are among the first wave of large-production, mainstream products that are taking CBD out of the neighborhood head shop, dispensary or hippie health food store and into mainstream commerce.
It fits into a new conception of health, wellness and functional foods that includes the nonintoxicating benefits of this chemical compound without the psychoactive THC found in marijuana.
But at the federal level, CBD in food and drink is still illegal. The Federal Food, Drug & Cosmetic Act prohibits adding even approved drugs to human or animal food in interstate commerce.
The 2018 Farm Bill legalized hemp, but the legal status of hemp-derived cannabidiol remains in limbo. This is largely because CBD can be derived from hemp or cannabis, but if a hemp plant contains more than 0.3 percent THC (the active “high” ingredient in marijuana) it is then technically a “marijuana” plant. It’s confusing. Experts say drafting and implementing regulations could take years.
Amy Abernethy, the FDA’s principal deputy commissioner, has taken the lead on clarifying the agency’s position on regulation of CBD-infused products, using Twitter as a primary mechanism for conveying the agency’s thought process.
On June 16, the FDA released a document called “What you need to know (and what we’re working to find out)” that states, “We are aware that there may be some products on the market that add CBD to a food or label CBD as a dietary supplement. Under federal law, it is currently illegal to market CBD this way.”
When asked which instances of CBD sale might prompt legal action, the FDA said it had no additional comments but that the agency had opened a docket for the public to submit comments through July 2. There are 2,554 comments thus far and that date has been extended to July 16.
From Ben & Jerry’s to Coca-Cola, brands are chomping at the bit to launch CBD-infused products, and stores like Walgreens, Kroger and CVS have vowed to sell them. More than 1,000 CBD-infused products are now available online.
Why the rush?
Oki beverages have a suggested retail price of $5 per 16-ounce a bottle; a 16.9 ounce bottle of Nestle water, by comparison, is about 54 cents. Boris Savransky’s Beezy Beez, which produces honey from a network of more than 200 bee farms in New York and New Jersey, started producing Hempme CBD-infused honey a year ago. Twelve ounces of his regular honey costs $5.99 to $6.99; six ounces of CBD-infused honey is $55. For honey, that’s a sweet markup.
Until now CBD products have been mostly tinctures, lotions and capsules, local or regional mom-and-pop items sold at dispensaries and often offshoots of the marijuana industry. Oki, with 360,000 bottles produced so far, aims bigger.
“Many of these companies stay intrastate because of bandwidth and financial resources,” said Garrett Graff, managing attorney at Hoban Law Group in Denver, which calls itself the nation’s premier “cannabusiness” law firm and represents more than 200 cannabis and hemp companies, including Oki.
Very few of the companies Graff’s firm works with have the ability to scale up to meet the ongoing supply needs of a major grocery chain or big-box store, yet market research firm Brightfield Group predicts the CBD oil business could balloon to a $22 billion market by 2022. Being among the first “marquee” national brands has the potential to be very lucrative.
In 33 states and D.C., medical marijuana is legal. In 10 of those states (plus D.C.) recreational marijuana is legal.
Amid that legal patchwork, each state is adopting its own strategies for dealing with CBD in food and beverage. Indiana, Utah, Texas and Florida require a QR code that allows consumers to look up batch numbers, potency and other ingredients. In May, Oklahoma Gov. Kevin Stitt approved a bill to establish labeling requirements for CBD and hemp extracts. In Florida, a state hemp program goes into effect July 1 establishing licensing requirements and a framework for dealing with violations, corrective measures and enforcement in the sale of CBD products.
So far, the FDA has looked the other way for intrastate commerce in CBD foods (Carls Jr. rolling out a CBD-infused “special sauce” burger in Denver for “4/20 Day,” say).
But interstate sales are thornier. Many banks, insurance companies and merchant service companies are leery of providing services for national CBD companies and of the FDA stepping in to see if the claimed CBD levels are present in the products (spoiler: they frequently aren’t) and issuing warnings to companies making “egregious and unfounded claims that are aimed at vulnerable populations,” claims that it cures Alzheimer’s, cervical cancer, fibromyalgia and other diseases.
Jim Bailey, the chief executive of Oki’s parent company Phivida, said there’s enormous potential in CBD – even though Oki labels make no mention of CBD, preferring to advertise “active hemp extract” to satisfy skittish retailers.
“Define what luxury means to you today. It’s health and wellness, and there’s a movement back toward plant-based foods and functional foods. We started looking at CBD uses for anxiety and insomnia,” Bailey said.
Oki water labels and marketing materials make no claims beyond, “”feel calm, feel balanced.”
But the sheer scale of Oki’s launch might arouse the FDA’s ire. Produced and bottled outside of Dallas, waters from the Vancouver-based company are likely trucked through states like New Mexico where marijuana remains illegal before reaching their final retail outlet – the very definition of interstate commerce.
Industry experts predict the launch of scalable commercial CBD products will force the FDA to expedite a federal regulatory framework.
“States are confused and lost and seeking guidance,” Graff said. “Even bullet points like ‘comply with good manufacturing practices’ and ‘don’t make impermissible health claims.’ If you had that interim guidance, you’d see huge relief among states.”
Graff and other experts are confident the FDA will soften its stance that CBD is not “safe as a food additive,” perhaps taking cues from Canada where new rules governing the production and sale of edibles go into effect Oct. 17. But questions remain about what CBD does, how safe it is and whether companies and even consumers open themselves up to legal action in partaking before a regulatory framework has been hashed out.
Because hemp has historically been coupled with marijuana, there has been little scientific research into safe dosages, drug interactions and the long-term effects of CBD use.
The University of Mississippi is the only federally authorized researcher of marijuana. Otherwise researchers must obtain materials through the National Institute on Drug Abuse. Graff said many companies have sought to do research with universities but have been stymied by red tape.
Graff said that many companies embrace third-party testing of products and “sensible” inspection.
“We all want the same thing in terms of consumer safety. That’s the same for any other product out there. Hemp should be treated equally under the law.”
This article was written by Laura Reiley, a reporter for The Washington Post.